Compare Your Options: Platforms, Channels & Approaches

sociallybold / compare.ts
Decide / Compare

Compare your options before you spend anything.

Plain comparisons of the platforms, channels and approaches a small business actually has to choose between. Written to help you decide, including when the honest answer is that you don’t need us.

◉Capability, control, maintenance and exit — not a scoreboard
◉Every comparison names the situation each option actually suits
/** * compare * No winner declared unless one option really is better for you. */
How these are written

A comparison is only useful if it can go against us.

Most “X vs Y” pages on agency websites reach the same verdict every time: hire the agency. That is not a comparison, it is an ad with a table in it, and readers see through it immediately. So these pages are written with a rule: if an option we don’t sell is the right answer for a particular kind of business, we say so, name that business, and explain why.

✓

We compare on what you live with

Capability, how much control you keep, who can edit the site afterwards, the maintenance burden, time to launch, how it handles growth, how much of your SEO you can actually change, accessibility, and what happens when you want to leave.

✓

We don’t compare on cost

Not because it doesn’t matter — it matters a lot — but because any figure we publish would be wrong for your project by the time you read it. We describe which option asks more of your money and which asks more of your time, and leave the numbers for a real conversation.

✓

We don’t compare firms

These pages compare technologies and approaches. We don’t rank other agencies, name them, or set ourselves against them. If you want to judge us, the pages below will tell you how we think, which is more useful than a logo wall.

✓

We separate fact from judgment

Where a trade-off is a matter of how a platform works, we say so. Where it is our opinion formed from building these sites for 10+ years, we label it as our view and explain the reasoning, so you can disagree with it.

The comparisons

Pick the decision you’re actually facing.

Start with the one closest to the question in front of you. Each page ends in a recommendation, not a shrug.

✓

Platform for an online store

WordPress (WooCommerce) vs Shopify — the honest split is between a store that is the whole business and a store that is one part of a content site.

✓

Local SEO or broader SEO

Local SEO vs SEO — two different results pages, two different sets of ranking factors, and one of them you may be able to run yourself.

✓

Fix the site or start again

Website redesign vs rebuild — what carries over, what doesn’t, and the case for doing neither this year.

✓

Where the site lives

Managed WordPress hosting vs shared hosting — the variable that decides this is not the host.

Also worth reading

Comparisons already on the blog.

These cover the same ground in article form. If one of them answers your question, read it instead — there is no reason to make you click twice.

✓

WordPress vs Webflow vs custom

Three ways to build the same business website, and which kind of team each one suits.

✓

Website builder vs web designer

Wix and Squarespace against hiring someone. Includes the sites that genuinely should stay on a builder.

✓

Web design agency vs freelancer

Two ways to buy the same work, and the risks that sit on each side.

✓

Google Ads vs SEO

Which to start with when you can only start one, and when running both stops being a luxury.

✓

Google Ads vs Local Services Ads

Pay per click or pay per lead, and which categories qualify for the second.

✓

Google Ads vs Facebook Ads

Paid search against paid social. Worth knowing that we run Google, Microsoft and Local Services Ads and do not run social ads, so the second half of that comparison is not something we sell.

✓

Mobile app vs mobile website

Most businesses that ask for an app need a faster website. This explains the exceptions.

✓

Native vs cross-platform apps

One codebase or two, and what each choice costs you in capability.

✓

Custom software vs off-the-shelf

The question is whether your process is genuinely unusual or just undocumented.

✓

WordPress vs a custom CMS

When a bespoke admin is worth maintaining forever, which is rarer than it sounds.

✓

Website design vs development

Not a choice — two jobs people often buy thinking they bought both.

✓

Is WordPress still worth it?

A straight answer about the platform most of these comparisons involve.

Reading any comparison

Four things to distrust, including on this site.

✓

A feature table with no losers

If one column wins every row, the table was built backwards from the conclusion. Real platforms trade capability for simplicity; a table that hides the trade is hiding the point.

✓

“Enterprise-grade” and similar

Words that describe no property of the software. If a claim can’t be checked by opening the product or its documentation, treat it as decoration.

✓

Silence about leaving

Every platform is easy to join. The question that separates them is what you can take with you — your content, your URLs, your customer data, your design — and how much has to be rebuilt. Ask it early, while you still have a choice.

✓

A recommendation with no “unless”

Any honest recommendation has a boundary. If nobody will tell you the conditions under which their advice stops applying, you have been sold to, not advised.

When the answer isn’t us

Situations where hiring an agency is the wrong move.

This is our view, formed from quoting work we then talked people out of. It is not false modesty: a project that shouldn’t exist goes badly for everyone, and we would rather say so in advance.

✓

A two or three page site for a sole trader

If you need a name, what you do, a phone number and a contact form, a website builder will do it well and you will be able to change it yourself at 9pm. Spend the attention on your Google Business Profile instead, which is where those customers actually find you.

✓

A site that is converting and just looks dated to you

Dated is not the same as broken. If the phone rings and the forms come in, a redesign risks what works. Measure first; redesign vs rebuild covers how.

✓

Marketing before the basics

Ads and SEO multiply what already happens. If calls go to voicemail, quotes take a week, or nobody follows up, that is the constraint, and no channel fixes it.

✓

One person who can do it all

Some businesses genuinely have someone capable in-house who enjoys this work. Give them a budget for tools and training before you give it to an agency.

Proof

Rated 5.0 on Google by 33 clients.

What we have to show for 10+ years is 100+ launched websites and apps, a 5.0 rating from 33 Google reviews, and our own site scoring in the 90s on Google’s mobile PageSpeed test. Clients include Kish Enclosures, Rainier Inc. and Cowford Can Co. Our team holds every current Google Ads certification.

Common questions

FAQ

Why don’t these comparisons include prices?

Because a figure published on a page is wrong for most of the people who read it. Scope, platform, content volume and how much of the work you do yourself change the answer completely. We describe which option asks more of your budget and which asks more of your own hours, and give real numbers in a scoped conversation.

Do you ever recommend an option you don’t sell?

Yes, and the pages say so explicitly. A website builder for a very small site, Shopify for a store-only business, doing your own Google Business Profile upkeep — all of those appear as recommendations here. We would rather be the firm you trusted than the firm you hired once.

Do you compare yourselves against other Jacksonville agencies?

No. These pages compare technologies and approaches, never firms. We don’t publish rankings of other agencies, and we don’t think a page where the author picks the winner would tell you anything useful.

How often are these updated?

When something changes that would change the advice — a platform altering what you can control, or a search feature shifting where attention goes. We would rather revise four pages honestly than keep twenty up to date badly.

Can you just tell me which option to pick?

Usually, yes, once we know three things: who will edit the site after launch, whether you serve a local area or sell everywhere, and what already works that you can’t afford to break. Those three answers decide most of these comparisons.

What if I disagree with a verdict here?

Then the page did part of its job. Each recommendation shows its reasoning so you can test it against your own situation, and several of these decisions are genuine judgment calls where a sensible person could go the other way. We say which ones those are.

$ ready_when_you_are()

Stuck between two options? Tell us the three facts above and we’ll tell you which way we’d go.